Skip to main content

Are Homeless New Yorkers Dangerous?

 

Are Homeless New Yorkers Dangerous or Violent?

Photo Credit: Freedom Life - stock.adobe.com

It seems like the only time that the mainstream news media ever mentions New York City’s homeless population is in connection with some violent act allegedly perpetrated by a member of this unfortunate demographic. Such coverage might lead you to conclude that those experiencing homelessness pose a threat to public safety. But that is not the reality. This blog post will endeavor to explode the myth that homeless New Yorkers are inherently dangerous while also discussing how to protect them from being victims themselves.

Are Homeless New Yorkers Violent? 

Every population - be it stably housed or otherwise, of one ethnicity or another, rich, poor, middle class - has its share of individuals who engage in acts of violence. In many cases, this is the result of trauma and/or untreated mental illness, and heaven knows that those experiencing homelessness have experienced more than their fair share of trauma in their lives. 

However, while homeless individuals are arrested at higher rates than their stably housed peers, those arrests tend to stem from nonviolent offenses. At the same time, the United States Interagency Council on Homelessness has found that even though rates of severe mental health or substance use disorders are high among homeless populations, a majority of those without stable housing do not have any mental health or substance use disorder. In fact, the same source found that the majority of Americans with such disorders do not experience homelessness. 

Are Homeless New Yorkers Susceptible to Violence?

Actually, homeless individuals are much more likely to be the victims of violence than perpetrators. To quote the Benioff Homelessness and Housing Initiative from the University of California San Francisco, “violence directed at homeless people is constant, mundane and devastating.” Homeless individuals often lack the basic protection that those with a safe, reliable place to live take for granted - i.e. a lockable door - and, unless the incident or incidents are particularly “newsworthy,” crimes against them go unreported. Some additional risk factors include being: 

  • Black, Hispanic and/or Native American
  • Lesbian, gay and/or transgender
  • A cis-female
  • Mentally or physically unwell, and/or
  • An older individual

One study found that homeless individuals face the following unfortunate statistics:

  • 19 times greater risk of murder

  • 27 times greater risk of attempted murder

  • 12 times greater risk of assault

  • 9 times greater risk of sexual assault

How Do We Protect the Homeless From Violence? 

Much like with other aspects of homelessness, the surest means of curtailing violence against this vulnerable population is to provide them with permanent supportive housing. When homeless individuals are housed, their risk of experiencing violence is halved. [1] Furthermore, once housed, they may receive treatment to reduce or prevent their susceptibility to future victimization. 

Mentor A Promise and its network of partner organizations is committed to ending this cycle of violence and empowering all New Yorkers to achieve the best possible outcomes. 

Contact Mentor A Promise Today 

Our organization recognizes the immense potential within each individual and seeks to provide them with the educational resources and opportunities they need to thrive. To that end, we have built a strong network of family shelters, educational institutions and community organizations to support homeless children, youths and their families. Click these links to learn more about what we offer or to get involved. Together, we can break the cycle of homelessness.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Can Art Heal Homeless New Yorkers?

Photo Credit: BillionPhotos.com - stock.adobe.com Writers and thinkers from Yuvi Noah Harari, author of Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind , to Lee Child, author of the Jack Reacher series, have posited the theory that homo sapiens survived prehistory while other human species went extinct due to our species’ ability to tell stories and engage in other artistic forms. This blog post will discuss how Art can heal homeless New Yorkers as well as where they may express themselves.  Does Art Have Healing Properties for Homeless New Yorkers?  With all the threats facing humanity, Art can seem like a luxury. However, throughout human history, Art has brought solace, toppled tyrants and given voice to the voiceless. Free expression is every bit as critical to our survival as nourishing food, clean water, suitable clothing and a safe, reliable place to lay our heads at night. This applies even to those experiencing homelessness.  How Does Art Heal Homeless New Yorkers? Aside ...
1 comment
Read more

How Often Do Formerly Unhoused New Yorkers Relapse Into Homelessness?

Photo Credit: FollowTheFlow - stock.adobe.com  To most outside observers, regaining safe, reliable housing seems like the end of the story. However, to continue to belabor this metaphor, this positive development is only the close of one chapter in a much longer narrative. Remaining healthy and housed is a neverending struggle. As such, many of those without the proper support network are at risk of returning to the streets and/or shelters. This blog post will discuss how often formerly unhoused New Yorkers relapse into homelessness, why this might happen and what can be done to prevent this.  Why Do New Yorkers Relapse Into Homelessness?  Homelessness, like many other chronic conditions, is akin to a disease, not a moral failing. Just as those struggling with alcoholism or drug addiction may relapse multiple times before treatment takes hold, homelessness is a cycle. This is especially true if the underlying traumas are not adequately addressed. As such, many of the same...
1 comment
Read more

Summertime Hunger Among Homeless New York Children

Photo Credit: SerPhoto - stock.adobe.com For many children, summer break is a time of excitement and exploration, free from the demands of school and extracurricular activities. But for the less fortunate children of New York City and elsewhere, the summer is a period of anxiety and deprivation. Without the breakfasts and lunches provided to them by their schools, these children will experience food insecurity and, yes, even hunger. This blog post will discuss summertime hunger among homeless New York City children, its prevalence, its impact on developing minds and bodies and how we can assist this vulnerable population.  How Common Is Summertime Hunger Among Homeless Children in New York City?  Before we delve into the numbers, the authors of this blog post would like to state that hunger is not exclusive to the summer months, nor is it constrained merely to young people who lack a safe, reliable place to sleep at night. Indeed, many New Yorkers from low income families expe...
1 comment
Read more