Should You Ever Hand a Homeless Person Money?

 

Should You Give a Homeless Person Money?

Photo Credit: guy2men - stock.adobe.com

If you are at all like the authors of this blog post, your heart breaks when you see someone braving traffic just to beg a few meager dollars from indifferent passersby. You may have reached for your wallet but stopped when you remembered that old refrain, which we shall not repeat here. But is there any truth to it? This blog post will examine whether you should ever hand a homeless person money on the streets of New York City. 

Is It Wrong to Give Money to a Homeless Person? 

According to one school of thought, which includes the late Pope Francis, it is not wrong to give homeless people money directly and it is none of our business how it is spent. To give the other argument some credit, it is true that around 38 percent of homeless people abuse alcohol and approximately 26 percent abuse other substances. [1] These illnesses may not be readily apparent. However, the overwhelming majority of this population, which includes thousands of families, is just trying to afford their basic necessities. Therefore, a few dollars could improve their chances not just of daily survival but set them on the path to recovery. 

Giving the same amount of money to an organization that works with the homeless, conducts research and performs other functions may maximize your impact with a larger group of people. Nonetheless, we should stress that, under the proper circumstances, both options can be effective. 

Does Giving a Homeless Person Money Help Them? 

Whether you give directly to one individual or to a charitable organization, we advise you to exercise discretion and situational awareness. If you donate to an organization, you should conduct some research beforehand to ensure they are spending the money in the most efficient manner. Likewise, before you give a homeless person money, you should, if the circumstances warrant it, first affirm their humanity and determine, to the best of your ability, their immediate needs by striking up a conversation. If you feel comfortable doing so and trust your instincts, you shouldn’t feel guilty about giving another person a little financial help, especially if you’re coming from a place of love. 

Is Donating Money Enough to Help the Homeless?

Regardless of where you send your money, it’s just as important to establish human connections with the recipients of your generosity. For example, after donating to a soup kitchen, you might consider volunteering there. Your presence is just as valuable as your presents. A friendly smile and a kind word can make a huge difference. 

If you want to help this population, or need help yourself, look no further than Mentor A Promise and its network of partner organizations. 

Contact Mentor A Promise Today 

Our organization recognizes the immense potential within each individual and seeks to provide them with the educational resources and opportunities they need to thrive. To that end, we have built a strong network of family shelters, educational institutions and community organizations to support homeless children, youths and their families. Click these links to learn more about what we offer or to get involved. Together, we can break the cycle of homelessness. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Permanent Supportive Housing Cheaper Than Shelters in New York City?

Image
  ali - stock.adobe.com In previous blog posts, we have frequently made reference to the high cost of living in New York City. On average, the monthly cost of living can range from approximately $4,441 for a single person to around $10,033 for a family of four. This makes New York the most expensive city in the U.S. and among the top 0.1 percent of most expensive cities in the world. [ 1 ] These statistics no doubt contribute to New York being home to the largest homeless population in the U.S. [ 2 ] Nevertheless, this blog post will discuss why it is cheaper to provide the homeless with permanent supportive housing than to pack people into shelters.  What Is The Cost of Homelessness in New York? You might not realize it, but there is a society-wide cost to the homelessness crisis. The exact costs will vary depending on the individual, but homelessness can cost taxpayers up to or in excess of $44,700 a year per chronically homeless person. [ 3 ] And yes, this number takes into...
Read more

How Do People Become Homeless in New York?

Image
 Photo Credit: Lumos Maxima - stock.adobe.com  Many myths persist about homelessness and those who experience it. Some of the most pernicious are in service to the lie that only certain types of people, for one reason or another, will lose stable housing. While some groups and individuals are more prone to being homeless, the truth is that anyone, under the just the wrong set of circumstances, could find themselves without a safe, reliable place to live. This blog post will examine how people become homeless in New York City, who is most susceptible to this condition and how one might work their way back from the brink.  How Does A New Yorker Become Homeless?  Although New York City consistently ranks as one of the world’s most expensive cities to live in, unaffordability is only one of the many causes of homelessness. As discussed in a previous blog post , domestic violence is responsible for approximately 40 percent of cases within the city shelter system. In all l...
Read more

What Does City of Yes Mean?

Image
  Photo Credit:  THANANIT - stock.adobe.com This blog discusses content also covered in our new podcast, available here .  We all know the cliché: “If you can make it in New York City, you can make it anywhere.” But for far too many New Yorkers, prosperity and success remain out of reach, exemplified most poignantly by the city’s dearth of affordable housing. To combat this growing crisis, Mayor Eric Adams proposed the “City of Yes” initiative. This blog post will examine its aims, potential benefits and whether it will be sufficient to solve New York’s housing crisis.  What Is The City of Yes?  According to the municipal government website, the City of Yes is a three-part plan to revise zoning laws, which haven’t been updated since 1961, to promote environmental sustainability, economic opportunity and, of course, increase the number of affordable housing units available. [ 1 ] These complex plans are intended to address a wide range of interconnected issues th...
Read more